<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:itunes="http://www.itunes.com/dtds/podcast-1.0.dtd" xmlns:googleplay="http://www.google.com/schemas/play-podcasts/1.0"><channel><title><![CDATA[Pub(lishing) Crawl: Greatest Hits]]></title><description><![CDATA[The most popular posts on the old website.]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/s/greatest-hits</link><generator>Substack</generator><lastBuildDate>Wed, 13 May 2026 23:30:42 GMT</lastBuildDate><atom:link href="https://publishingcrawl.com/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/><copyright><![CDATA[Pub(lishing) Crawl]]></copyright><language><![CDATA[en]]></language><webMaster><![CDATA[publishingcrawl@substack.com]]></webMaster><itunes:owner><itunes:email><![CDATA[publishingcrawl@substack.com]]></itunes:email><itunes:name><![CDATA[S. Jae-Jones]]></itunes:name></itunes:owner><itunes:author><![CDATA[S. Jae-Jones]]></itunes:author><googleplay:owner><![CDATA[publishingcrawl@substack.com]]></googleplay:owner><googleplay:email><![CDATA[publishingcrawl@substack.com]]></googleplay:email><googleplay:author><![CDATA[S. Jae-Jones]]></googleplay:author><itunes:block><![CDATA[Yes]]></itunes:block><item><title><![CDATA[Ask PubCrawl: Breaking into the Industry]]></title><description><![CDATA[By the PubCrawl Crew]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/ask-pubcrawl-breaking-into-the-industry</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/ask-pubcrawl-breaking-into-the-industry</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Pub(lishing) Crawl Podcast]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 10 Jun 2016 07:00:00 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We here&nbsp;at PubCrawl try our best to elucidate different aspects of the industry for you via our posts and&nbsp;<a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/category/pubcrawl-podcast/">podcast</a>,&nbsp;but we are also available to answer questions (as best we can) if you <a href="http://mailto:publishingcrawl@gmail.com">email</a> us or send us an <a href="http://publishingcrawl.tumblr.com/ask">ask through Tumblr</a>. PubCrawl alumna <a href="http://www.alexandrabracken.com">Alex Bracken</a>&nbsp;used to do a feature&nbsp;for us called <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/tag/ask-alex/">Ask Alex</a>&nbsp;where she would answer more industry-focused questions, and we've gotten a few about publishing programs.</p><p><strong>From Bev:</strong></p><blockquote><p>Hi, I hope I'm directing this question to the right place&#8212;I'm a graduating senior English major and I'm potentially looking at two options in Professional Publishing programs for the summer, NYU SPI and the Columbia Publishing Course. Does anyone have any insight into what the differences are between the two? From what I can tell, Columbia seems more focused on book publishing: is this true, and can anyone testify to whether this helped you more as a writer? I know that Columbia doesn't provide a professional certificate and that NYU does, but I'm not really sure what a professional certificate merits. Overall, I'd be extremely grateful for insight from anyone who employs students from these programs (or doesn't) or anyone who's attended or had experience with either. Thank you!</p></blockquote><p> Hi Bev, I have not attended a professional publishing course, but I have known several people who have, including our very own Alex, who wrote about summer publishing programs <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2013/04/02/ask-alex-publishing-institutes/">here</a>. In her post, she says that it appears that Columbia focuses more on book publishing while NYU focuses more on digital/magazine publishing.</p><p>As for whether or not this has helped anyone as a writer, I can confidently say&nbsp;<em><strong>probably not</strong></em>. Both of these professional programs are focused on the&nbsp;<strong>business</strong> of publishing, not the&nbsp;<em>craft</em> of writing. However, if you are looking for insight into how the industry works, they 're incredibly useful and enlightening. A few of my editor colleagues attended these programs before and after they began working in publishing, for various reasons, and they say the mileage they've gotten from them depends on the work they've put into it. Another one of my editor colleagues used to teach a seminar about editing at NYU.</p><p>As for who employs students from these programs, I do know that the Big 5 routinely recruits from these programs; one of my good friends went to CPC and she was hired based on her interview from their job fair. I would say both publishing programs are about equal in terms of post-course hiring; like any industry, the connections you make are just as important as what you learn about it.&nbsp;In&nbsp;addition to publishing courses, I would highly recommend internships. Each of the Big 5 and other midsize and small presses offer them, as well as literary agencies. I got my start in publishing via an internship at a literary agency; I did not attend a publishing course.</p><p><strong>From Liv:</strong></p><blockquote><p>Hi Pub Crawl! I was recently accepted to Columbia's Publishing Program at Exeter College and can't wait to get started! It's might hope to find a career in book marketing or publicity. However, I'm a little concerned and have a couple of questions I hope you'll be able to answer... 1) I just graduated with a Bachelor's of Business Administration, so I don't exactly have an extensive education in literature studies. How essential is it to be familiar with the classics and/or things like common literary themes, narrative structures, critical theories, etc. when you work in publishing? 2) For the past couple of months, I've been trying to learn as much as I can about the industry (that's how I found your amazing blog!), but I was wondering if you might have any recommendations for other sources? Thank you so much! Sorry that this is such a long message. Love you guys and your posts! Best, Liv</p></blockquote><p> Hi Liv, many people who work in publishing did not major in literature in college. Some majored in communications, and others majored in the sciences. It is not essential to be familiar with the "canon" of literature to work in publishing; all you need is a genuine love and enthusiasm for books. I was an English major in undergrad and I can tell you that as an editor, I employed exactly&nbsp;<em><strong>zero percent</strong>&nbsp;</em>of the knowledge I gained in class. Academic criticism has no place in publishing.&nbsp;And even some of literary terms you might have learned in school mean something different in the business, like <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2016/05/05/pubcrawl-podcast-introduction-to-genre/">genre</a>. I would also argue that studying&nbsp;<strong>writing</strong> and not&nbsp;<em>literature</em> is far more useful in the industry, in terms of narrative structure and tropes. As an editor, some of this would be important, but to be honest, as an editor, I was more concerned with whether or not the book I was editing was a good story (if fiction) and/or written in a clear, engaging, and readable way (if nonfiction).</p><p>As for other sources on the industry, I would recommend you check out the archives of Kristin Nelson's blog <a href="http://nelsonagency.com/pub-rants/">Pub Rants</a>. She is a literary agent, so much of her advice is author-focused, but she also has incredibly useful information about contracts, royalties, and money. If you're interested in an editorial perspective, I would recommend you check out <a href="http://www.cherylklein.com">Cheryl Klein</a>'s website, where she's posted some of her speeches and talks, and will be coming out with a nonfiction book about editing and writing.</p><p><strong>Hope this helps, y'all! If you have any more questions, let us know in the comments or via email and Tumblr!</strong></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Doing Your Research: The Query Trenches Part Three]]></title><description><![CDATA[By Hannah Fergesen]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/doing-your-research-the-query-trenches-part-three</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/doing-your-research-the-query-trenches-part-three</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Hannah]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 16 Oct 2015 07:00:54 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hey all, Hannah here! Last week, I spoke in depth about how to summarize your novel for a query. The month before, I gave some tips on little ways to take yours to the next level. Today, I'm going to go into a bit more depth about some of the larger mistakes I often see that might give agents a reason to reject a query.</p><p>This is a hard truth: many agents receive hundreds of queries a week, and yours will, someday, be among them. When an agent reads so many queries every day (if they are lucky enough to find the time among all of their other responsibilities), it sometimes becomes easier to find reasons to reject a query, rather than reasons not to.</p><p>The number biggest reason a query gets rejected, aside from simply not fitting an agent's list or tastes? A query that betrays poor to no research. So without further ado, here are some mistakes I regularly see that tell me a querier has jumped the gun.</p><p><strong>Mistake: Telling instead of showing.</strong></p><p>Yes, this is true in queries as well as fiction. Every so often I'll see a query that has a very short summary, often even more like a logline, detailing the very broad plot points of the story, followed by many paragraphs explaining character motivation and themes.</p><p>For example:</p><blockquote><p>When a girl and a boy are thrust into an emotional situation, they are forced to confront the realities of friendship and go on a search for the meaning of life.</p><p>I wanted to write this book because the themes of lost love and identity speak to me, and, as someone who has experienced a terrible breakup, I felt I was the best person to tell this story. Michelle and Tony are best friends but I wanted to drive an emotional wedge between them in the form of a third love interest.</p></blockquote><p> Etc.</p><p>This tendency comes from not knowing how to summarize your story. Rather than over-explaining to the point of confusion, the story is under-explained to the point of being too broad. Anyone who still doubts their ability to summarize their novel well should check out last week's post for guidance. Because an agent should be able to tell quite clearly from the stakes you outline in the summary what your character's motivations are.</p><p><strong>Mistake: Explaining this is the first book you've written/that it's recently completed OR calling this your debut/yourself a debut writer</strong></p><p>This is a mistake because it highlights you as possibly inexperienced whether you are or want to be framed that way. It isn't pertinent information - it changes nothing about your story, how you summarize your story, or anything within your bio. The only thing it does is tell me that there's a possibility you haven't done your research.</p><p>There is no need to point out if this is your first book or your fiftieth. Let the work speak for itself.</p><p><strong>Mistake: Confusing "personalizing your query" for "restating the submission page on the website"</strong></p><p>This actually a very easy mistake to make. We often see advice that suggests personalizing a query by telling the agent why you chose him or her. This shows the agent that you didn't just mass email your query - you took time and put thought into who you contacted.</p><p>But what I often see instead of <em>"I noticed quirky, adventurous middle grade on your #MSWL, and felt my manuscript fit the bill"</em>, is: <em>"I went to your website and saw that you are looking for thrillers and upmarket fiction and romance and that you enjoy working with new authors. Therefore I am emailing you."</em></p><p>Here's the thing: the agent knows what's on the website. Don't waste valuable query space repeating it. That space should be for you and your story. And if you don't have something more specific to personalize with, that's okay! If you chose the agent based on what the website says he or she wants, just start with your hook and go from there.</p><p><strong>Mistake: Naming more than three characters.</strong></p><p>A long, confusing summary often gets that way when too many characters are named in a query. The moment you name a character is the moment you tell a reader that character is important. Perhaps you have more than one main character &#8211; maybe you have five, or seven! It doesn&#8217;t matter. Pick your most important character, the one whose struggle your book is ultimately about, and focus your query on him or her. After that, only name those who absolutely must be named in relation to the <em>summary</em>. If you can help it, try not to name more than three characters. The person reading your query will (hopefully) be far less confused.</p><p>One of the things I struggled with when querying was exactly this problem &#8211; knowing who to name and who to leave out. But trust me: it can be done.</p><p><strong>Mistake: Using bad comp titles.</strong></p><p>This one is actually really hard to get right, in my opinion, and if you aren't entirely certain, just don't use them. Do they help? Only if they're spot on.</p><p>Using books that are huge sellers/extremely well-loved is generally a no-no. Why? Because comparing yourself to J.K. Rowling or Suzanne Collins or Stephen King goes back to the <em>haughty </em>or <em>poorly researched </em>issue. It's much safer to use titles that do/have done well enough and are known, but not so huge that you look arrogant or ignorant of other good books. It's also <em>generally </em>best to use something more current - more than a couple years old and they begin to lose relevance.</p><p>See? Told you it was tough.</p><p>Another question I sometimes get: can a querier use TV shows or films as comp titles? The answer is...yes and no. Tread lightly here. I wouldn't use more than one TV/film comp title, and if you do, it's often helpful to balance it with a book title. Lots of agents feel differently in this category - some hate when queriers use TV/film titles, and some really like it. If you aren't sure, do your research. Check out an agent's twitter, interviews they have done, etc. If there are no answers to be found and you aren't 110% certain of the titles you've chosen? Skip them. This is another area where it's best to err on the side of caution.</p><p>It's true that there are writers who make mistakes like these and still get agents. All of publishing is subjective - what bothers one agent may not bother another. The format one agent loves, another might hate. But being informed and well-researched shows in a query, no matter who you're querying. And that is far more valuable than you realize.</p><p><strong>Once again, I hope this has been useful. Good luck to everyone in their querying endeavors!</strong></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Summarizing Your Novel: The Query Trenches Part Two]]></title><description><![CDATA[By Hannah Fergesen]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/summarizing-your-novel-the-query-trenches-part-two</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/summarizing-your-novel-the-query-trenches-part-two</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Hannah]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 09 Oct 2015 07:00:25 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hey guys! Hannah here. Last month, I posted some tips on little ways to take your query out of the blah zone. JJ and Kelly also posted an <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2015/09/24/pubcrawl-podcast-publishing-101-querying-representation/">awesome podcast on the query process</a>.</p><p>When giving query advice, a lot of us take for granted that you'll know what we mean when we tell you a query must have a short synopsis of your story. We also take for granted that you'll figure out how to do this in 300 words or fewer. I'd like to talk a bit more about what goes into creating a good, cohesive summary that will entice an agent to read more in just a few paragraphs.</p><p>You've probably seen a lot of advice that tells you a good query is comprised of a hook followed by a summary of your story, ending with a bio and a few sentences on why you chose the agent you are querying. Structurally, this is sound. But when you have a sprawling epic with many perspectives, or even a quietly complex contemporary, it can be tough to know how best to distill your story into a summary that makes sense.</p><p>What I usually see in the slush is this: a summary that goes over many of the big points in the plot but rushes through due to lack of page space and direction. The agent reading might miss key plot points, or have no idea what that made-up word is. Maybe the summary began too deep into the story, and the agent is confused by the list of events. These questions are distracting for a query reader, and can bring them out of a query quick.</p><p>So how do you summarize your novel and do it well? We have a tendency to think we must somehow shove the entire plot into this tiny space. But that isn't actually the case. The best summaries (even the sprawling, epic ones) contain these: your inciting incident, your main conflict, the plan, and the stakes.</p><p>Before we get into the summary, let's talk about <strong>the hook</strong>. There are two reasons why your hook is so important. <em>Number one</em>: It's the hook! Okay, that one is obvious. It's designed to give agents a peak into your character that entices them into reading more. <em>Number two</em>: if done well, it should help you cut huge swaths of fluff from your summary.</p><p>A good hook tells us about the character and the conflict in one go. I'm taking this example of a hook from Erin Bowman's post <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2015/08/14/querying-the-dos-and-donts-and-a-worksheet/">Querying: The Do's and Don'ts</a> (thanks, Erin!), to show you what I mean:</p><blockquote><p>Gray Weathersby is counting down the days until his eighteenth birthday with dread, for in the primitive and isolated town of Claysoot, a boy&#8217;s eighteenth is marked not by celebration, but by &nbsp;his disappearance.</p></blockquote><p> We know who the main character is, we know something personal about him when the book opens, and we know what his conflict is going to be. I'm intrigued to keep reading.</p><p><strong>Next:</strong> What is an inciting incident? This is that moment when the status quo is no more, and the character is forced to take action. This is a step I often see skipped in queries, resulting in a strangely disjointed summary.</p><p>Figure out what the inciting moment is for your character, and tell us about it. For example, a precious jewel is stolen from a museum&#8212;this is the catalyst for the Private Eye to enter the picture and solve the mystery. Or, your protagonists loses her job and instead of applying elsewhere, chooses to fulfill a dream and travel the world. Tell me about the moment when everything your character thought she knew is turned on its head.</p><p>Now that your character has been called to action, tell us what needs to be accomplished. This is where you flesh out your conflict. We don't need each and every detail; just enough to show us what the protagonist must overcome. The P.I. must now solve the mystery of the stolen diamond&#8212;but a nefarious gang will stop at nothing, including murder, to prevent it from happening. And, the more the P.I. digs, the more he unearths about a political conspiracy (give some detail on that conspiracy) attached to the diamond theft. The World Traveler has all of her money stolen in a foreign country. The hostel where she was staying burns down with all of her worldly possessions. Maybe she, too, stumbles into a political conflict she knows nothing about.</p><p>So what are your characters going to do about it? They have decisions to make. These decisions are informed by the stakes. For a lowly P.I., getting in the middle of a nefarious gang AND a political conspiracy might not be worth it. So tell me why he gets involved anyway. Is he blackmailed? Does he have a personal tie to a person or plan within the gang or the conspiracy? Tell us why he MUST solve the murder, and what is at stake for him if he doesn't. For the World Traveler who has lost everything, tell us how she plans to get home, what she must sacrifice to do it, and what happens if she fails. Is her father dying back home? Is her sister getting married? Is her house set for demolition? Why is it important for her to overcome this conflict?</p><p>A note on fantasy: it's very tempting to try and give all the backstory about the world, its magical systems, its government, or its religion. These are things you've worked hard on - your story is not the same without these elements. But if character IS story (and it is), then the most important thing is to make us understand your character's struggle at the most basic level. Leave the made-up words and the complicated hierarchies out of the query.</p><p>When you look at the summary in this way, you can see that even sprawling epics can be broken down into short summaries. These components make up the heart of the story, and that's what an agent wants to see in a query.</p><p><strong>I hope this has been useful! If anyone is interested in a Part Three, let me know below!</strong></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Diving Headfirst Into the Query Trenches]]></title><description><![CDATA[By Hannah Fergesen]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/diving-headfirst-into-the-query-trenches-2</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/diving-headfirst-into-the-query-trenches-2</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Hannah]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 02 Sep 2015 07:00:48 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Guys. Queries are hard. This is an undisputed fact of the agent-acquiring process. These days a lot of agents ask for the first 5-30 pages of your manuscript when you query, because it&#8217;s so much easier to tell if a story is good by reading, well, the actual story. But the query is the hook&#8212;the bait that gets the agent past that first page and into your story.</p><p>I read queries on the daily. A lot of them. As a literary assistant, it&#8217;s one of my many responsibilities. I need to be able to tell, just from that one page, if your book is something the agent and I will want to read. I need to see just how I would pitch it to an editor. And I need to see that you know your stuff. Have you done your research? Or did you scribble off a quick note and hit SEND ALL?</p><p>The queries that stand out are either very good, or very bad. But there are a lot of queries that get stuck in the middle&#8212;that strange wasteland of almost-there, but just not quite. Chances are, a lot of you are in that boat. Most of us, even those who have agents, have written blah query letters. And I know PubCrawlers are smart. You have done your research, much of it on this very website. I don't need to tell you not to send attachments, or not to write your bio in the third person. I don't need to tell you not to call your manuscript a future bestseller, the most unique piece of fiction ever written, a story that will apply to all of the audiences that ever existed!</p><p>So I&#8217;m not going to talk about the basics. You guys KNOW the basics. I&#8217;m going to talk about those little things that maybe don&#8217;t seem problematic at first glance. But fixing these can go a long way toward helping the viability of your query overall</p><h4>1. Don't start your letter with all the details about how you came to write this book.</h4><p> Writing is exciting. How you came to be a writer is exciting. The fact that it&#8217;s your first, or second, or millionth novel ever is exciting. But they are most exciting to you&#8212;in a query, these things clog up your first paragraph and waste valuable space. Before he or she has ever met you or read your work, an agent doesn&#8217;t care how you got started writing. As much as it matters to you (and it does matter!), it&#8217;s best to leave it out. It will not change how he or she feels about your story.</p><h4>2. Be careful creating &#8220;atmosphere&#8221; before launching into your hook.</h4><p> It can feel gimmicky. Unless your setting is basically a character itself, it&#8217;s best to stay away from this method. For example:</p><blockquote><p>Castle Pelimere is deep and dark, inhabited by angry spirits and on the verge of certain doom. For a hundred years it has stood, and now, thanks to the Everlasting Nothing that has circled its walls for centuries, it is all about to come crashing down.</p><p>Jody Brody is a teenage pickpocket with no other skills and no other prospects. When Castle Pelimere needs a hero, Jody steps up to the plate.</p></blockquote><p>I know, I know&#8212;this is a <em>very</em> obvious example. But it serves the point&#8212;character is story, and when I&#8217;m scanning through queries, I&#8217;m more interested in Jody Brody the pickpocket than the plight of Castle Pelimere.</p><h4>3. Don&#8217;t relate two unrelated ideas in your hook.</h4><p> You would be shocked how often I see this. Shocked, I tell you. An example:</p><blockquote><p>Marty Schmarty is not your typical jock&#8212;he&#8217;s been taking ballet since before he could walk, and he&#8217;s better than half the girls in his class. But when he&#8217;s offered a football scholarship to his dream school, he learns what it really means to be part of a team.</p></blockquote><p>Again, another extreme example. But writing a good hook is a huge part of the battle when it comes to queries. A good hook can make me perk up and pay attention. In this case, the writer has written something that &#8220;sounds hooky&#8221; and &#8220;adds character&#8221;. It makes me pay attention&#8212;then has no pay-off. Marty&#8217;s a pro at ballet, and this is set up as a key quality&#8212;then is not mentioned again.</p><h4>4. Be confident...to a point.</h4><p> There is nothing wrong with being proud of the story you wrote. It takes a huge amount of confidence to query a book (we&#8217;re all writers here, we can admit this). But it&#8217;s not up to you to decide whether your writing is of the same caliber as authors you have emulated or been inspired by, or if it&#8217;s beautifully lyrical or powerful and gritty&#8212;that is for your readers, and that includes any agents you are querying, to decide.</p><h4>5. Be wary of the false choice.</h4><p> Technically, a <em>false choice </em>refers to a situation where two choices are given as the only possible option&#8212;even though more choices may be viable. In this case, I&#8217;m using to describe it as a situation given in a query, wherein a character has what appear to be two choices&#8212;but only one of those choices is actually viable. Still with me?</p><p>Okay, so you&#8217;ve laid out your hook, given a short synopsis, and now it&#8217;s time to present the dramatic question. Your character must do x or y. But when you present a false choice, it becomes clear right away which path your character will and must choose. At first glance, it isn&#8217;t always clear you&#8217;ve presented a false choice. For example:</p><blockquote><p>Jake must choose between saving the woman he loves from the mob and escaping to the Bahamas, or turning himself in and confessing to his crimes, even if it means her death.</p></blockquote><p>Maybe turning himself in might be the <em>right</em> thing to do, but unless this is a morality play, the choice here is not actually black and white. When questions like this are presented at the end of a query, I can&#8217;t help but roll my eyes&#8212;I <em>know</em> what Jake is going to do. He&#8217;s going to choose the Bahamas. And if he doesn&#8217;t, then you need to do a fantastic job of setting up the <em>why</em> within your query. Again, the above is extreme example, but I encourage you to take a look at the stakes in your own query and find out whether what you&#8217;ve presented is a real dilemma, or a false choice. I want the questions you present to make me go, &#8220;MUST READ AND FIND OUT THE ANSWER!&#8221;</p><p>So the gist of these suggestions comes out to: Make me want to read your book. Seriously, give me no other option. You wrote a whole book. You know how to put words together on a page&#8212;this is just a different kind of writing. One that forces you to think about how to condense what you've written, and lay it out in a way that is tight and enticing. I promise you&#8212;it is doable. It's hard, it's often confusing, and sometimes it can take multiple drafts to get right. But it can be done!</p><p><strong>I hope this is useful, and I wish everyone who is currently writing their query, Good Luck!</strong></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Revision for Pantsers]]></title><description><![CDATA[by S. Jae-Jones]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/revision-for-pantsers</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/revision-for-pantsers</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[S. Jae-Jones]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Mon, 18 May 2015 07:00:33 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I recently finished a fairly major revision on my contracted novel that nearly killed me.</p><p>How did it almost kill me?</p><p>I wrote 32,000 words in 7 days in order to get it turned in on time. (I essentially rewrote the entire last act of the book from scratch.) Why did I throw out the last third of my book?</p><p>Because it made it better.</p><p>Here's the thing about revision: I hate it. I am Team First Draft; I like the process of discovery and the blank page. For me, not knowing how a book will turn out is the most exciting thing of all.&nbsp;It may be because I'm a Panster (or a Gardener, as G.R.R.M. says), or it may be because I'm just like that in general. As an artist, I tended to prefer my sketch work to my more finished pieces; as a musician, I would learn a piece just well enough to play competently (but with great expression!).</p><p>My actual editorial letter was fairly light: about four pages, which essentially boiled down to 1. trim words from the first act and up the pacing, and 2. make the ending stronger and more emotionally resonant.</p><p>So why I did throw out all those words?</p><p>Because I was being weighed down by the baggage of the old draft.</p><p>As a member of Team First Draft, I find writing new words easier than fixing old ones.&nbsp;It's really more of a mental trick than a writing one, but I know some of our readers have been asking for revision help, and I thought I would offer my revision process thoughts from the perspective of someone who is, ah, less systematic than everyone else, i.e. a disorganized mess. (The irony here is that I'm pretty systematic in nearly every other aspect of my life, including <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2012/06/14/how-i-edit/">editing</a>.)</p><p>Revising by hand, because I am Old School.</p><p>Let me backtrack for a moment here. When I was an editor, the first editorial letter I wrote generally addressed large, structural questions. What I called the <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/tag/story-question/">Story Questions</a> (which I've discussed many times in writing for PubCrawl). The first edit is generally the biggest and most encompassing because what you are doing is shoring up the foundations of the novel. Editorial letters for the structural edit are deceptively "light" because it's not specifics that need addressing; it's the larger picture.</p><p>The larger picture is both the easiest and hardest thing to fix, at least it is for me. It's the easiest because it's often one thing that "clicks" into place and makes everything better, and it's the hardest because of the amount of WORK required. Because one small change might affect&nbsp;<em>every single interaction</em> a character has throughout the entire book. Just as a small tremor on one side of an ocean can cause a tsunami on the other, these little changes can sometimes add up to A GIANT KILLER WAVE THAT WASHES AWAY THE LAST ACT OF YOUR BOOK.</p><p>The thing about being a Pantser is that you don't necessarily have the larger picture in mind when you're drafting. Or rather, you do, but it's buried deep in your subconscious, so you're not necessarily thinking about it when you're writing. A Pantser is what I call an Inside-Out writer; someone who "starts small" and builds into a whole. To continue with the Gardener metaphor started by G. R. R. M., a Pantser plants one seed, then another seed, then another seed, and before you know it, you have an entire of forest of words.</p><p>By necessity, an editor is an Outside-In thinker. Someone who looks at the picture as a whole, then drills down to the smaller levels. I think Plotters are also Outside-In thinkers: they begin with the foundations, and add layers. G. R. R. M. calls Plotters Architects, people with blueprints. The entire revision process is really an Outside-In process, and for Inside-Out writers, it can be awfully hard to wrap your mind around it.</p><p>Case in point: me. As an editor, I can certainly think Outside-In; I like building information systems and finding ways to break large concepts into easily digestible components. But as a writer, I simply can't work that way. When I am writing, I can only look at the scene I'm working on; if I think about how that scene fits into my novel as a whole, my brain breaks.</p><p>So how to fix this problem? I "write my book again from scratch", but this time, as an Outside-In thinker. In other words, I take my novel and break it down into an outline, i.e. reverse-outlining. I don't outline fiction the way I used to outline my non-fiction: starting with I. Theme, and breaking it into A. Subtheme, B. Subtheme, etc. Instead, I write what I call the "long, shitty synopsis": <em>Once upon a time, there was a girl with music in her soul who lost her sister to the goblins.&nbsp;</em>Essentially, <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2013/09/04/telling-yourself-the-story/">I tell myself the story</a> all over again with my editor's comments in mind, and then I write it again with all new words. (It's like first-drafting! I like first-drafting!)</p><p>Granted, I don't ACTUALLY write an entirely new book during revisions; in fact, I'd say 85% of the time, I keep the words I've already written. I sometimes even re-type them to trick myself into thinking I'm writing new words. For me, so much of writing is about momentum, the feeling of forward motion, and the thought of slowing down and FIXING what I've written (out of order!) hinders more than helps.</p><p><strong>What about you? Do any of our readers have as much difficulty with revision as I do? Do you have any tips? Share in the comments!</strong></p><p>[hr]</p><h3>Further revision resources:</h3><ol><li><p>Our own <a href="http://susandennard.com">Sooz</a> wrote a&nbsp;<em>fantastic&nbsp;</em><a href="http://susandennard.com/links/for-writers/">guide to revising</a> on her website, complete with character, plot, and world building worksheets, which you should all check out.</p></li><li><p>Our own Jodi Meadows also wrote posts on revision, <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2015/02/04/revision-part-one-of/">here</a>, <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2015/03/06/revision-part-two-of-three/">here</a>, and <a href="http://www.publishingcrawl.com/2015/04/06/revision-part-three-of-three/">here</a>.</p></li></ol>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[The Life of a Query Letter]]></title><description><![CDATA[By Jordan Hamessley]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/the-life-of-a-query-letter</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/the-life-of-a-query-letter</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 19 Feb 2014 04:00:28 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Authors, it's time for another session of Publishing Secrets from Jordan. This one is about that query letter you're writing or spent lots of blood, sweat, and tears making perfect. Here it is.</p><p>Once you've signed with an agent, your query letter <strong>NEVER DIES!</strong></p><p> Want to know what I'm talking about? Let's hear from literary agent extraordinaire<a href="https://twitter.com/LindsayRibar"> Lindsay Ribar</a>!</p><blockquote><p>If a query letter is good enough to have caught my eye in the first place, chances are good that I'll at least use key phrases from it, if not an edited version of the entire plot description, for my pitch letter.</p></blockquote><p>Many agents I know pull from an author's query letter for the pitch letter sent to editors when a book goes on submission. But that's not the end of the life of a query. Now it's the editors turn! Before I make an acquisition, I have to convince my publisher, along with the sales and marketing team, why we should publish a book and what makes it special. </p><p>Obviously, if I love a book, I'll have a clear idea of what to say, but I always look back at the pitch letter to get inspiration for my own "pitch" to the decision makers. I always have to find comp titles for any manuscript I want to acquire. While I often come up with additional comps, the first comps I encounter are the ones from the pitch letter. Chances are, your agent came up with their initial comp titles by looking at your query. </p><p>OK. Good news. Your query got you an agent! WAHOO! Their pitch helped the editor buy the book. CONGRATS! Think we're done with your query letter? NOPE! Now it's time to convince booksellers and reviewers to pick up the book by writing catalog and sales copy! Where does that come from? The editor's own pitch to the sales and marketing team! See where I'm going with this? Your query is still alive and well. At this point, the comp titles and what makes this book stand out from the rest are featured in the copy. And what makes YOU, the author, special. </p><p>The last stop on your query's tour of the publishing industry is cover copy. By the time an editor is writing copy, you will probably only see hints of of query, but there is a good chance part of it is still alive and kicking in your book's cover/jacket copy. </p><p>So there you have it. Your query goes beyond so much more than getting the attention of an agent. It will live with your debut until it ends up on the shelf. No matter how frustrated you may get as you write and revise your query, remember to love it. It will be with you for your entire publishing debut journey.</p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[How To Write A 1-Page Synopsis]]></title><description><![CDATA[By Susan Dennard]]></description><link>https://publishingcrawl.com/p/how-to-write-a-1-page-synopsis</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://publishingcrawl.com/p/how-to-write-a-1-page-synopsis</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Sooz]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2012 05:00:43 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37f1e4bf-3b4f-4c1b-8262-2382d4792c12_100x100.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>One thing writers hate doing but will inevitably have to do (one day or another, at least) is the Dreaded Synopsis. An agent may request it in his/her submission materials, or an editor might want it once your agent has you out on subs. My film agent needed it for shopping around <em>Something Strange &amp; Deadly</em>, and I would imagine other rights-agents would want a short, simple synopsis for the same reason. So in other words: you have to learn to do this. You need it before you're published, and you'll certainly need it afterwards.&nbsp;Specifically, you'll need to be able to write the 1 or 2-page synopsis. </p><p><em>But Sooz,</em> you say. <em>It's hard to boil my&nbsp;whole ingenious novel into a few key sentences.&nbsp;To convey the depth, the emotion, the literary power of your novel in 500 words or less&#8212;impossible!</em> </p><p>Ah, but <em>is</em> possible my friends.&nbsp; It's possible and can even be&nbsp;<em>fun (</em>if you enjoy mental torture like me). &nbsp;</p><p>To learn how to write a short synopsis,&nbsp;I took workshops, read books, and wrote a few drafts until I had a gleaming 1-page book summary.&nbsp;And after all that practice, I realized I had my own method (built from the methods of my various teachers, of course), and I'm sharing that method with you here. To use this worksheet, fill out the questions in sentence form. Though your story may not follow this exact format, try to find some critical event in the story that can be placed in that space.&nbsp;</p><p>You will likely notice that the worksheet is <em>very</em> similar to the <a href="http://wp.me/p1VRPr-LY">Hero's Journey </a>(because most stories follow that format!), and I have filled out the questions using my All Time Favorite Movie as the example. Once you have filled out the worksheet, rewrite them on a fresh sheet of paper and try to eliminate words, tighten sentences, and variate sentence structure. </p><p>How many words do you have? You want to shoot for under 500, and you want to have some &#8220;space&#8221; left for inserting connective words (e.g. meanwhile, then, after, etc.). You also want to have extra space to add any events that are needed for explanation/flow. </p><p><strong>Rule of thumb:</strong> You should only name three characters in a short synopsis&#8212;usually, the protagonist, antagonist, and possible love interest/side-kick/contagonist. All other characters should be referred to by their roles (e.g. the waitress, the mother, the basketball player). <br><strong>Rule of thumb:</strong> You must tell the ending! The purpose of a synopsis is to show an editor/agent you can tell a story from beginning to end. You will not entice them into reading your whole MS if you don't share the ending&#8212;you'll just tick them off! :) <br><strong>Rule of thumb: </strong>Do not include subplots unless you have extra space at the end!!!!!&nbsp; Stick to the MAIN PLOT EVENTS.</p><div><hr></div><h3>Fill in the Blanks</h3><h4>1. Opening image</h4><p> An image/setting/concept that sets the stage for the story to come.</p><p><em>Long ago, in a galaxy far away, a controlling government called the Empire takes control of planets, systems, and people. Anyone who resists is obliterated.</em></p><h4>2. Protagonist Intro</h4><p> Who is the main character? Give 1-2 descriptive words and say what he/she wants.</p><p><em>Luke Skywalker, a na&#239;ve farm boy with a knack for robotics, dreams of one day escaping his desert homeland.</em></p><h4>3. Inciting incident</h4><p> What event/decision/change prompts the main character to take initial action.</p><p><em>When he buys two robots, he finds one has a message on it&#8212;a message from a princess begging for help. She has plans to defeat the Empire, and she begs someone to deliver these plans to a distant planet. Luke goes to his friend and mentor, the loner Ben Kenobi, for help.</em></p><h4>4. Plot point 1</h4><p> What is the first turning point? What action does the MC take or what decision does he/she make that changes the book's direction? Once he/she crossed this line, there's no going back.</p><p><em>Ben tells Luke about a world where the Empire rules and Rebels fight back, where Jedi Knights wield a magic called the Force, and how Luke must face Darth Vader &#8211; the man who killed Luke's father and now seeks to destroy Luke too. Luke refuses, but when he goes back to his farm, he finds his family has been killed. He has no choice but to join Ben.</em></p><h4>5. Conflicts &amp; character encounters</h4><p> Now in a new life, the MC meets new people, experiences a new life, and meets the antagonist/villain.</p><p><em>To escape the desert planet, Ben and Luke hire a low-life pilot and the pilot's hairy, alien friend. Luke, Ben, Luke's robots, the pilot, and the hairy friend leave the planet and fly to the Death Star, Darth Vader's home and the Empire's main base.</em></p><h4>6. Midpoint</h4><p> What is the middle turning point? What happens that causes the MC to make a 180&nbsp;degree change in direction/change in emotion/change in anything? Again, once he/she has crossed this line, there's no going back.</p><p><em>Once on board the Death Star, Luke discovers the princess is being held as a hostage. He and the group set out to find the princess, while Ben sets out to find a way for them to escape the base.</em></p><h4>7. Winning seems imminent, but...</h4><p> What happens that makes the MC think he/she will win? She seems to have the upper hand, but then oh no! The antagonist defeats her and rushes off more powerful than ever before.</p><p><em>After rescuing the princess, Luke and the group try to escape. Ben sacrifices himself so they can flee, and Darth Vader kills Ben. The group flees the Death Star on their own ship.</em></p><h4>8. Black moment</h4><p> The MC is lower than low, and he/she must fight through the blackness of his/her emotions to find the strength for the final battle. What happens here?</p><p><em>Luke is devastated over Ben's death, and he is more determined to fight Darth Vader and help the Rebels defeat the Empire. Luke joins the Rebel army, and helps them plan an attack on the Death Star's only weakness.</em></p><h4>9. Climax</h4><p> What happens in the final blow-out between the MC and the antagonist?</p><p><em>The Death Star arrives in space near the Rebels, and the attack begins. Luke joins the assault team of fighter ships. The Rebels suffer heavy losses, and soon Luke is one of the few remaining pilots and ships. He takes his chance and initiates the final attack. Guided by Ben's voice and the Force, he manages to fire the single, critical shot to explode the Death Star.</em></p><h4>10. Resolution</h4><p> Does everyone live happily ever after? Yes? No? What happens to tie up all the loose ends?</p><p><em>With the Death Star destroyed and the Empire severely damaged, the Rebels hold a grand ceremony to honor Luke and his friends. The princess awards them with medals for heroism.</em></p><h4>11. Final image</h4><p> What is the final image you want to leave your reader with? Has the MC succumbed to his/her own demons or has he/she built a new life?</p><p><em>Though Luke is still sad over the loss of Ben and his family, he has found a place among the Rebels, and with them, he will continue to fight the Empire.</em></p><div><hr></div><h3>Putting It All Together</h3><p>Long ago, in a galaxy far away, a controlling government called the Empire takes control of planets, systems, and people. Anyone who resists is obliterated. Luke Skywalker, a na&#239;ve farm boy with a knack for robotics, dreams of one day escaping his desert homeland. When he buys two robots, he finds one has a message on it&#8212;a message from a princess begging for help. She has plans to defeat the Empire, and she begs someone to deliver these plans to a distant planet. </p><p>Luke goes to his friend and mentor, the loner Ben Kenobi, for help. Ben tells Luke about a world where the Empire rules and Rebels fight back, where Jedi Knights wield a magic called the Force, and how Luke must face Darth Vader&#8212;the man who killed Luke's father and now seeks to destroy Luke too. Luke refuses, but when he goes back to his farm, he finds his family has been killed. He has no choice but to join Ben. </p><p>To escape the desert planet, Ben and Luke hire a low-life pilot and the pilot's hairy, alien friend. Luke, Ben, Luke's robots, the pilot, and the hairy friend leave the planet and fly to the Death Star, Darth Vader's home and the Empire's main base. Once on board the Death Star, Luke discovers the princess is being held as a hostage. He and the group set out to find the princess, while Ben sets out to find a way for them to escape the base. After rescuing the princess, Luke and the group try to escape. Ben sacrifices himself so they can flee, and Darth Vader kills Ben. The group flees the Death Star on their own ship. </p><p>Luke is devastated over Ben's death, and he is more determined to fight Darth Vader and help the Rebels defeat the Empire. Luke joins the Rebel army, and helps them plan an attack on the Death Star's only weakness. The Death Star arrives in space near the Rebels, and the attack begins. Luke joins the assault team of fighter ships. The Rebels suffer heavy losses, and soon Luke is one of the few remaining pilots and ships. He takes his chance and initiates the final attack. Guided by Ben's voice and the Force, he manages to fire the single, critical shot to explode the Death Star. </p><p>With the Death Star destroyed and the Empire severely damaged, the Rebels hold a grand ceremony to honor Luke and his friends. The princess awards them with medals for heroism. Though Luke is still sad over the loss of Ben and his family, he has found a place among the Rebels, and with them, he will continue to fight the Empire. </p><p><strong>FINAL WORD COUNT: 452</strong> </p><div><hr></div><p>I hope this helps you all!&nbsp; I know I use it as a general guide every time I write a synopsis. &nbsp;Sometimes, I even use it <em>before</em> writing a novel to help me get an idea of the general plot I want to follow. </p><p><strong>What about you?&nbsp;</strong>How do <em>you</em> write a synopsis? Or do you have any questions about this method? </p><div><hr></div><p>Want a<strong> FREE&nbsp;guide to writing a query letter?</strong> What about<strong> weekly writing advice </strong>and<strong> insider tips?</strong> Then sign up for my newsletter<strong>,&nbsp;the&nbsp;<a href="http://eepurl.com/P1JzH">Misfits &amp; Daydreamers</a>,&nbsp;</strong>or swing by<strong>&nbsp;<a href="http://susandennard.com/links/for-writers/">my For Writers page</a>!</strong></p>]]></content:encoded></item></channel></rss>